P&A Providers & Administrators
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

The Seesaw Effect

There will be compliance challenges for auto dealers, even while Trump is in office.

by Terry O'Loughlin
February 10, 2025
The Seesaw Effect

Car dealers may be the most regulated and disfavored industry by consumer advocates in the United States.

Credit:

Pexels/Minh Tran

4 min to read


Elections have consequences, proclaimed a former president. Those consequences portend pendulum swings regarding governmental regulation, and prosecutions, especially for auto dealers.

Regulation declines when conservative forces ascend to power. Conversely, regulation becomes a major thrust when liberal or progressive political elements take control of the government. Car dealers may be the most regulated and disfavored industry by consumer advocates in the United States and become a major target in the latter case. “Disfavored” in this context means a business whose consumer-protection policies are allegedly questionable and hence needing further scrutiny and regulation. The proposed CARS Rule, Junk Fee Rule and other regulations in the past few years bear evidence of these oscillations.

Ad Loading...

The New Nonregulation Environment 

President Trump has said that any new regulation should pair with the repeal of 10 existing regulations. The ratio was one regulation per two repealed ones in his previous administration. In French, the concept is laissez-faire, literally “allow to do” or “let them do it,” an economic policy which advocates for minimal economic government intrusion. This fiscal reasoning ostensibly furthers free markets, which are believed to produce more wealth for society and thereby enhance personal prosperity. 

The Great DOGE Eraser – Excising the CFPB

A case in point is the vow of the Department of Government Efficiency, or DOGE, spokesman, Elon Musk, when he endorsed eradicating the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. This avowal is consistent with the Project 25 agenda, which recommends both abolishing the CFPB and reversing Section 1061 of the Dodd-Frank Act.  These actions would return those transferred functions to their original agencies. For example, the Federal Reserve would once again oversee the regulation of the Truth in Lending Act. 

Prosecutorial Discretion

In addition to striking current regulations and not adding new ones, the Trump administration plans to employ prosecutorial discretion. This discretion is the authority of an agency to decide how to enforce the law against alleged violators. The Federal Trade Commission, for example, will probably not be as vigorous in its prosecutions under the new administration. 

Nature Abhors a Vacuum – When the Teeter is Down the Totter is Up

Progressive politicians abhor a regulation vacuum. The alphabet collective of consumer rights groups, DAGA, PIRG, CFA, NCLC, NACA, ABA, CRL and Public Citizen, along with the ever-eager class-action bar, are preparing to fill this vacuum and totter up. Public Citizen, for example, criticized Musk’s call to eliminate the CFPB as “intolerable corruption.” A major newspaper proclaimed that “[democratic] attorneys general have also become the muscle of the resistance.” Trump’s first administration was sued 155 times by blue-state attorneys general. There is little doubt that certain state attorneys general will increase their role by ramping up their own enforcement actions, as well as participating in multistate actions on dealer infractions. Considering that complaints about cars are the most common complaint state attorneys general receive, dealers need to be vigilant. The NCLC National Consumer Law Center issued a press release about the new Trump administration which is essentially a rallying cry for consumer advocates: “In this second term, we will redouble our efforts to partner with civil rights and grassroots organizations to defend consumer rights.”

State Mini-CFPBs

When Trump first took office in 2017, many states sought to fill a perceived gap in areas previously overseen by the CFPB, creating new consumer-protection agencies or departments, informally deemed “mini CFPBs.” Various states, such as California, Maryland, New Jersey and Pennsylvania, began these programs, with other states adding subagencies for these purposes. The programs will likely be reinitialized to correct for the expected discontinuance of regulatory and prosecutorial activity.

Ad Loading...

Conclusion – A Word to the Wise

A potential dearth of federal regulatory activity will not yield an absence of consumer law enforcement. There will probably be an increase of investigations and prosecutions in the blue states since those government officials will be more alert to absent federal action. Consumer advocates in the red states will attempt to compensate for this absence. However, all federal and state consumer-protection agencies are required to enforce the law, and they shall continue doing so if the offense warrants such action. Smart dealers will be watching both ends of the seesaw and continue their sanguine compliance efforts. 

Originally posted on F&I and Showroom

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Industry

White Tesla Model Y from rear
Industry•by Hannah Mitchell•November 17, 2026

EV Sales Making Post-Tax Credit Comeback

Both new and used sales are up from last October, when the demand-boosting credit ended, though used units are seeing the greatest gains.

Smiling man working on a new car in a Honda manufacturing plant
Industry•by Hannah Mitchell•November 10, 2026

Honda Embraces Hybrid Fever

The automaker plans a new Ohio factory, along with investments in existing U.S. and Canadian plants, to significantly boost hybrid production here.

Magnifying glass emphasizing the words “Social and Search” with various social media platform logos surrounding it.
Industry•by Lauren Lawrence•November 10, 2026

Dealerships Must Show Up Where It Matters

How car buyers find your dealership has fundamentally changed. New evidence reveals the importance of your presence on social media, Google search, and large language models.

Ad Loading...
Line of like-new vehicles in outdoor lot
Industry•by Hannah Mitchell•November 3, 2026

CPO Sales Could Take Off in the Right Conditions

A recent Cox Automotive consumer survey reveals the size of an undertapped market for the vehicle segment given affordability pressures.

Small black toy car on top of a map.
Industry•by Lauren Lawrence•November 3, 2026

Global Consumer Trends Diverge

Price remains a top consideration for U.S. car buyers, and they are the most brand-loyal consumers to established automakers, according to a new survey.

Two men and one woman standing in front of blue walled Chevrolet dealership entrance.
Industry•by Hannah Mitchell•October 27, 2026

Badger State Dealership Gets New Owner

The longtime southern Wisconsin store moved from one area auto group to another, keeping the business in Dairyland.

Ad Loading...
Two hands, one handing off set of keys to the other.
Industry•by Lauren Lawrence•October 27, 2026

The Cycle of Negative Equity

Third-quarter data shows consumers still rolling over debt and stretching loan terms, raising their risk of remaining underwater.

Orange electric vehicle charging station.
Industry•by Lauren Lawrence•October 20, 2026

Charger Network Growth Slows

Despite a projected increase in public EV chargers in 2026, charging infrastructure remains a top concern for consumers as the gap between the most and least EV-friendly places remains substantial.

Fan of $100 bills atop a white envelope
Industry•by Hannah Mitchell•October 13, 2026

Lenders, Consumers Take on More Auto Loan Risk

September records loosened credit access the most in over a decade as buyers took advantage of the conditions to afford trading, though loan applications fell.

Ad Loading...
Red type R Honda civic parked on road.
Industry•by Lauren Lawrence•October 13, 2026

Next-Gen Hybrids in Sight

Dealerships can expect to see revamped hybrids from Honda next year as the company rolls out a new system and model lineup.