P&A Providers & Administrators
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

NADA: Supply, Incentives Driving Down Retention Rates

October 12, 2016
3 min to read


MCLEAN, Va. — Through September, retention rates for most model-year 2013 vehicles are down across the board compared to last year, according to NADA Used Car Guide. Larry Dixon, the firm's director of market intelligence, said increased supply and incentives are the reasons.


“We estimate that the supply of used vehicles up to five years old will jump by 12% this year. This is the biggest increase in more than a decade," Dixon said. "As for incentives, with new-vehicle sales growth leveling off, manufacturers are dialing up incentives to preserve market share. Per J.D. Power, incentives were up 9% through August to an average of $3,436 per unit.”

Ad Loading...


Only mid-size vans, luxury large utility, sports cars and mid-size pickups retained their average value better this year compared to 2015, according to the report. And, out of those four segments, mid-size pickups held their value the most — holding an average of 67.2% of their value after three years.

Segment Retention Rates

  1. Mid-size Pickup: 67.2%

  2. Half-ton Pickup: 56.5%

  3. Mid-Size Utility: 53.7%

  4. Large Utility: 53.1%

  5. Lux Large Utility: 52%

  6. Sports Car: 51.2%

  7. Compact Utility: 50.7%

  8. Mid-Size Vans: 50.4%

  9. Lux. Sports: 50.2%

  10. Lux. Compact Util.: 50.1%

  11. Lux. Mid-Size Util.: 48.2%

  12. Compact Car: 46.5%

  13. Lux. Subcompact: 45.1%

  14. Lux. Compact: 43.7%

  15. Mid-Size Car: 43.6%

  16. Lux. Large Car: 42.4%

  17. Large Car: 42.2%

  18. Lux. Mid-size Car: 41.2%

  19. Subcompact Car: 37.5%

“Their versatility can’t be matched, and the road manners and fuel efficiency of today’s utility and pickup truck are significantly better than in the past. Availability — or the relative lack thereof — is also helping,” Dixon said in a statement issued to F&I and Showroom.


He added that although the supply of large pickups at auction is up about 28% compared to the year prior, it is still well below the pre-recession highs. Additionally, the relatively low price of gas, and the forecast of cheap gas to come is adding to the appeal of pickups.


However, while low gas prices are acting as a boon for pickups and utilities, it’s acting as a bane for subcompacts. The NADA Used Car Guide found that the subcompact segment retained its value the least out of all segments — 37.5% of its value after three years — and also realized the worst retention rate decline out of all segments — vehicles in the category dropping 7.2% in value compared to the year before.


Dixon said that the main reason for the decline in subcompact car retention is similar to the reason the industry as a whole is seeing declines in value retention: increased supply.

Ad Loading...


“It’s estimated that subcompact volume of vehicles up to five years old will grow by 20% [or more] this year, more than the vast majority of other segments,” Dixon said. “We’ve seen auction volume for the segment grow at a similar rate so far this year, 22%.”

Retention Rate Change From Year to Year

  1. Subcompact Car: -7.2%

  2. Large Car: -4%

  3. Compact Util.: -3.4%

  4. Lux. Subcompact: -3.2%

  5. Compact Car: -2.6%

  6. Lux. Compact: -2.5%

  7. Lux. Mid-size Util.: -2.2%

  8. Lux. Mid-size Car: -1.9%

  9. Lux. Sports: -1.9%

  10. Mid-Size Car: -1.6%

  11. Large Util.: -1.4%

  12. Half-Ton Pickup: -1.2%

  13. Lux. Compact Util.: -0.9%

  14. Lux. Large Car: -0.4%

  15. Mid-Size Util.: -0.3%

  16. Mid-Size Vans: +0.3%

  17. Lux. Large Util.: +1.5%

  18. Sports Car: +1.6%

  19. Mid-Size Pickup: +4.7%

While the average retention rates for the other car segments — compact, mid-size, large, luxury subcompact, luxury compact, luxury mid-size, and luxury large — were all below the larger utilities and pickups, their rates were noticeably better than subcompacts. At the low end were three-year-old luxury mid-size cars with a retention rate of 41.2%. At the high end were compact cars with a retention rate of 46.5% after three years.


Dixon also noted that while the subcompact segment is struggling, the luxury subcompact is holding its value much better than its non-luxury counterpart. In fact, the luxury subcompact segment is holding its value better than every other luxury car segment — the one exception being luxury sports.


The reason being is that luxury subcompacts are a less mature segment with less competition, Dixon noted. The segment, he added, also facilitates entry into the luxury sector because of the segment’s relative affordability vs. larger luxury vehicles.

More Industry

Smiling man working on a new car in a Honda manufacturing plant
Industry•by Hannah Mitchell•November 10, 2026

Honda Embraces Hybrid Fever

The automaker plans a new Ohio factory, along with investments in existing U.S. and Canadian plants, to significantly boost hybrid production here.

Read More →
Magnifying glass emphasizing the words “Social and Search” with various social media platform logos surrounding it.
Industry•by Lauren Lawrence•November 10, 2026

Dealerships Must Show Up Where It Matters

How car buyers find your dealership has fundamentally changed. New evidence reveals the importance of your presence on social media, Google search, and large language models.

Read More →
Line of like-new vehicles in outdoor lot
Industry•by Hannah Mitchell•November 3, 2026

CPO Sales Could Take Off in the Right Conditions

A recent Cox Automotive consumer survey reveals the size of an undertapped market for the vehicle segment given affordability pressures.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Small black toy car on top of a map.
Industry•by Lauren Lawrence•November 3, 2026

Global Consumer Trends Diverge

Price remains a top consideration for U.S. car buyers, and they are the most brand-loyal consumers to established automakers, according to a new survey.

Read More →
Two men and one woman standing in front of blue walled Chevrolet dealership entrance.
Industry•by Hannah Mitchell•October 27, 2026

Badger State Dealership Gets New Owner

The longtime southern Wisconsin store moved from one area auto group to another, keeping the business in Dairyland.

Read More →
Two hands, one handing off set of keys to the other.
Industry•by Lauren Lawrence•October 27, 2026

The Cycle of Negative Equity

Third-quarter data shows consumers still rolling over debt and stretching loan terms, raising their risk of remaining underwater.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Orange electric vehicle charging station.
Industry•by Lauren Lawrence•October 20, 2026

Charger Network Growth Slows

Despite a projected increase in public EV chargers in 2026, charging infrastructure remains a top concern for consumers as the gap between the most and least EV-friendly places remains substantial.

Read More →
Fan of $100 bills atop a white envelope
Industry•by Hannah Mitchell•October 13, 2026

Lenders, Consumers Take on More Auto Loan Risk

September records loosened credit access the most in over a decade as buyers took advantage of the conditions to afford trading, though loan applications fell.

Read More →
Red type R Honda civic parked on road.
Industry•by Lauren Lawrence•October 13, 2026

Next-Gen Hybrids in Sight

Dealerships can expect to see revamped hybrids from Honda next year as the company rolls out a new system and model lineup.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Dodge ram emblem on orange vehicle exterior
Industry•by Hannah Mitchell•October 6, 2026

Gem State Stores Change Hands

A larger auto group founded in the industry’s early years sold two franchises to a neighbor group that's on a growth spurt.

Read More →