Automaker Tesla's Direct-To-Consumer Sales May Already Be Illegal in Michigan
LANSING, Mich. – Electric vehicle manufacturer Tesla, known for bypassing dealers and selling directly to consumers, is afraid an amendment to an unrelated bill would prevent the manufacturer from doing just that, reported Michigan Live.
But the bill’s supporters say current law already precludes that.
That’s the understanding of Terry Burns, executive vice president of Auto Dealers of Michigan, who said “there’s no regulatory change at all in the amendments.”
At issue is HB 5606, which principally addresses a separate issue surrounding the fees auto dealerships charge for preparing documents. However, a language in a substitute from the Senate floor is raising red flags for some.
A Tesla executive told the Wall Street Journal the legislation would prohibit direct-to-consumer sales, and Automotive News has termed it an “anti-Tesla” bill. Tesla’s business model of direct-to-consumer sales has run into problems in other states.
Language in HB 5606 states that a manufacturer may not “Sell any new motor vehicle directly to a retail customer other than through franchised dealers, unless the retail customer is a nonprofit organization or a federal, state, or local government or agency.”
But the Auto Dealers and the bill's sponsor say that language isn't new.
The Secretary of State draws that from current law. MCL 445.1574 states that a manufacturer cannot “Sell any new motor vehicle directly to a retail customer other than through its franchised dealers, unless the retail customer is a nonprofit organization or a federal, state, or local government or agency.”
That's a one-word difference from what's in HB 5606.
HB 5606, which passed both chambers nearly unanimously, doesn’t have anything to do with Tesla, according to sponsor Rep. Aric Nesbitt, R-Lawton. It’s been amended, but “It still doesn’t have anything to do with Tesla,” he said.
He’s not gotten any feedback on the bill from Tesla, though he’s seen media reports. “It seems like they’re using this as kind of a red herring to talk about their issue, which is already covered under current law,” Nesbitt said.
Burns of the Auto Dealers said that the amendment was to clarify the bill’s application to all deals, as some have tried to claim exemptions in the past. It doesn’t represent a regulatory change, he said.
“All the original equipment manufacturers in the world that do business here comply with the law, and it’s worked very well,” Burns said.
Some don't think the current prohibition on direct-to-consumer sales is working well. Ted O'Neil, director of media relations for free market think tank The Mackinac Center, said allowing consumers to purchase directly from manufacturers would cut vehicle costs.
"We’ve come out in favor of abolishing basically auto dealer protectionism laws. We would think there’s nothing wrong with people who would be able to buy a vehicle directly from the manufacturer," O'Neil said.
He said the fact that a prohibition of direct sales already exists in Michigan is a product of strong lobbying and donations from auto dealers.
HB 5606 is on Gov. Rick Snyder’s desk, where spokesperson Dave Murray said staff is still reviewing it.
“They’re giving it the due diligence and review before making a decision,” Murray said.
The Governor has until Oct. 21 to act on the bill.
More Industry

World EV Adoption Set to Grow
A new report says the segment, despite recent setbacks in some regions, is poised for acceleration as many countries look to reduce pollution.
Read More →
Black Book: Weekly Market Update
Wholesale automotive auction business stayed steady last week as bidders encountered lower prices, analysts observed.
Read More →
Pricing Transparency Drives Purchase Consideration
An annual study by JD Power found that clear pricing matters to consumers on automaker websites, so much so that it increases their purchase consideration.
Read More →
Black Book: Weekly Market Update
Used-vehicle market depreciation was the prevailing story in the wholesale market last week.
Read More →
Smaller Is Looking Better
A growing number of Americans in the market for a new vehicle are opting for more affordable options, not waiting for market stability to bite the bullet.
Read More →
U.S. EV Market Slowly Stabilizes
U.S. electric-vehicle interest is slowly stabilizing since a major dip in sales after last year's end of the federal EV tax credit, and hybrids remain the leading electrified power train.
Read More →
Global EV Market Entering New Phase
Automakers are making investments to lower battery costs and optimize production to meet changing consumer needs.
Read More →
Black Book Weekly Market Update
The holiday weekend, not surprisingly, put a drag on wholesale automotive activity last week, analysts observed.
Read More →
Auto Affordability in Context
Cox Automotive points out the complex circumstances that have led to eye-popping vehicle prices.
Read More →
Black Book: Weekly Market Update
Automotive auction inventory increased last week, giving choosy bidders even more leeway.
Read More →