Report: GAP Claim Payouts Are Accelerating
Protective Asset Protection analysts say GAP claim payouts rose by 19.5% for new vehicles and an astounding 95% for used vehicles between 2014 and 2018.

Factors contributing to rising GAP claim payouts include a greater number of increasingly complex vehicles on the road, higher collision rates, and a rash of severe weather events.
Photo by Kim Jinhong via Pexels
CHESTERFIELD, Mo. — F&I products and reinsurance provider Protective Asset Protection released a new set of data analysis showing how much average claims have increased annually for guaranteed asset protection payouts and vehicle service contract claims dating back to 2014.
Between 2014 and 2018, the average new-vehicle GAP claim payout grew 19.5%, or 4.7% per year. For used vehicles, in the same timeframe, GAP payouts increased by 18.5% per year, producing a four-year total increase of 95%.
Analysts blamed several factors, including an increase in claims due to more collisions with more cars on the road. Also cited were insurance companies becoming more likely to total vehicles due to rising replacement parts complexity and corresponding costs. Falling residual values — particularly for cars, less so for trucks and SUVs — and more impactful weather events were blamed as well.
Average VSC claims have risen 21% between 2014 and 2018 for new vehicles, and a 3.7% increase for used vehicles. New vehicles have averaged a 5% increase each year during that time, with a smaller 0.9% increase for used vehicles.
“Service contract claims had among their largest payout increases in 2018 for both new and used vehicles, which illustrates that the costs associated with repairs and parts replacements continues to rise due to the complexity of today’s vehicles,” said Christopher Bernish, Protective’s senior vice president of operations and IT. “GAP claims are impacted by many of the same factors but also tend to be influenced by weather patterns, which is understandable, given recent devastating hurricanes and other weather events.”
Originally posted on F&I and Showroom
More Industry

Honda Embraces Hybrid Fever
The automaker plans a new Ohio factory, along with investments in existing U.S. and Canadian plants, to significantly boost hybrid production here.
Read More →
Dealerships Must Show Up Where It Matters
How car buyers find your dealership has fundamentally changed. New evidence reveals the importance of your presence on social media, Google search, and large language models.
Read More →
CPO Sales Could Take Off in the Right Conditions
A recent Cox Automotive consumer survey reveals the size of an undertapped market for the vehicle segment given affordability pressures.
Read More →
Global Consumer Trends Diverge
Price remains a top consideration for U.S. car buyers, and they are the most brand-loyal consumers to established automakers, according to a new survey.
Read More →
Badger State Dealership Gets New Owner
The longtime southern Wisconsin store moved from one area auto group to another, keeping the business in Dairyland.
Read More →
The Cycle of Negative Equity
Third-quarter data shows consumers still rolling over debt and stretching loan terms, raising their risk of remaining underwater.
Read More →
Charger Network Growth Slows
Despite a projected increase in public EV chargers in 2026, charging infrastructure remains a top concern for consumers as the gap between the most and least EV-friendly places remains substantial.
Read More →
Lenders, Consumers Take on More Auto Loan Risk
September records loosened credit access the most in over a decade as buyers took advantage of the conditions to afford trading, though loan applications fell.
Read More →
Next-Gen Hybrids in Sight
Dealerships can expect to see revamped hybrids from Honda next year as the company rolls out a new system and model lineup.
Read More →
Gem State Stores Change Hands
A larger auto group founded in the industry’s early years sold two franchises to a neighbor group that's on a growth spurt.
Read More →