Toyota Had Attack Plan, Records Show
Toyota officials sought to develop a public relations campaign to attack the credibility of
key witnesses who have testified before Congress about acceleration problems with the company's cars, according to documents provided to the House committee investigating the automaker, The Washington Post reported.
The effort was based in part on polling conducted for Toyota by Joel Benenson, President Obama's chief pollster. His poll questioned the integrity of the witnesses: Sean Kane, a Massachusetts safety consultant, and David Gilbert, an auto technology professor at Southern Illinois University Carbondale.
Congressional investigators have demanded to know from company officials whether a campaign to debunk or discredit their witnesses was put into action.
The company says it never produced advertisements based on the polling. Still, plans for the campaign have drawn the ire of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, which, upon learning of them, told the automaker to hand over all related documents.
Lawmakers "would take very seriously any effort to malign or intimidate witnesses who cooperate with our investigations," a committee spokesman said in a statement Friday.
In November, Toyota announced that it would replace accelerator pedals on about 4 million vehicles in the United States because they can get stuck in floor mats, causing
unintended acceleration. The problem has been linked to as many as 39 deaths.
In news coverage and in public testimony, Kane and Gilbert have been highly critical of Toyota's response to the acceleration issue.
Kane works with victims' lawyers and runs a blog that is critical of Toyota. Gilbert testified to Congress in February that he had conducted an experiment showing a flaw in the electronics of a Toyota engine that could explain some of the incidents of unintended acceleration. The company has denied that electronics are a factor.
In a statement Friday, Toyota said Gilbert and Kane had made "assertions" that had "created unwarranted consumer concern."
"Toyota, like most organizations, conducts regular public opinion research," the company said, adding that Benenson had "tested for the widest range of potential messages to measure effectiveness."
Political candidates and companies often use polling to test the weaknesses of their critics or opponents. Benenson's survey, titled the "Kane/Gilbert Debunking Message Test," directed pollsters to read several negative statements about Gilbert and
Kane. The survey noted that a study Kane had commissioned from Gilbert was "nothing more than a manufactured stunt -- a parlor trick that would affect nearly all cars the same way, not just Toyotas." Having heard that, respondents were asked to say
whether that changed their opinion of Kane's and Gilbert's credibility.
Benenson declined to talk about the matter, saying, "We have been doing work for Toyota for three years, and we don't discuss publicly the work we do for any clients."
Rep. Henry A. Waxman (D-Calif.), committee chairman, sent a letter to Toyota's president in late March demanding "all documents" relating to the poll. The matter is expected to be made public in a hearing next week.
Attorneys for Toyota responded to the committee in an least two letters. In one dated April 9, the company's top lawyer acknowledged that Benenson's survey results were used "primarily to guide the company's advertising development efforts. Ultimately, Toyota chose not to place advertising relating to this issue."
In their second response, on April 28, company officials cited a letter from Benenson submitted to the committee in which the veteran pollster said that "testing messages to rebut unfair or false assertions is a common and legitimate research practice and is no different than message testing our firm regularly does for Congressional candidates or Congressional campaign committees in response to critics or opponents."
According to documents provided to the committee, Toyota received advice about how to respond to Kane and Gilbert from Benenson and New York public relations firm Robinson, Lerer & Montgomery. The documents show that Benenson's firm, Benenson
Strategy Group, has conducted 25 surveys about Toyota's reputation since December 2009.
On Friday, Kane said he considered the automaker's attempts to discredit him as validation.
"If we weren't finding something that was meaningful, they wouldn't be spending this kind of time and money," he said in an interview. "But what we're seeing is that they're willing to go to great lengths to discredit anyone who asks questions about their products."
More Industry

Kia Closes Out Summer With a Bang
Its U.S. subsidiary broke multiple records in August, in part due to a surge of demand for hybrids models.
Read More →
Indiana Dealership Changes Hands
A 30-year-old Ford dealership in Indiana has a new owner and will soon be undergoing renovations to meet manufacturer requirements.
Read More →
Texas Dealership No Longer in the Family
The Ford store, a longtime cornerstone of the Houston market, is now part of one of the fastest-growing U.S. auto groups.
Read More →
Genesis Grows California Presence
The Cardinale Automotive Group opened its third Genesis rooftop in the Golden State, Genesis of San Bruno, a stand-alone dealership serving the San Francisco Bay Area.
Read More →
August Auto Sales a Mixed Bag
An early forecast shows strong business despite consumer hurdles, and hybrids are a big piece of their affordability coping strategy.
Read More →
EV Market Humming Along
July sales show steady growth as the segment stabilizes from last year’s artificial surge following pullback of federal support.
Read More →
Auto Loan Delinquency Rates Stabilize
Auto loans are a main driver of nonmortgage consumer debt, but delinquency rates stabilized in the second quarter across all credit risk tiers.
Read More →
EV Sales Recover in Q2
The EV sales roller coaster continues as numbers show improvement, but industry experts predict a year-over-year third-quarter decline and fourth-quarter jump.
Read More →
The Cheapest Hybrids to Fuel
The powertrain is increasing in popularity, in no small part due to its fuel economy. A new report lists the most efficient hybrids on the market.
Read More →
Hybrids and SUVs Gaining Ground
The most recent Kelley Blue Book Brand Watch found that only two nonluxury brands increased in shopper consideration, buoyed by their hybrid and SUV offerings.
Read More →